One of the key decisions you’ll need to make when choosing a helmet is which style is best for you. Full-face helmet designs offer the most coverage and protection, but flip-up helmet designs offer versatility and convenience that can appeal to some riders. So which one is the safest?
Modular or flip-up helmets are not as safe as full-face helmets, as the rotating chinbar creates a weak point in the helmet’s protection. However, when closed and locked, they offer just as much protection as a full-face helmet. In addition, there is evidence that the chin bar can open or detach completely in a crash.
In this article, we’ll take a closer look at the pros and cons of flip-up helmet designs, examine the safety standards that helmet manufacturers must adhere to, and present the results of any available real-world testing of flip-up helmet safety.
By the end of this article, you’ll better understand whether flip-up helmet designs are as safe as full-face helmet designs, and you’ll be better equipped to make an informed decision about which type of helmet is best for you.
The Pros and Cons of Flip-Up Helmets
One of the main benefits of flip-up helmet designs is their versatility.
These helmet styles feature a chin bar that can be flipped up, allowing the rider to communicate easily with others or take a drink without removing the entire helmet.
This can be especially convenient for riders who need to take breaks or make quick stops during long trips.
Another advantage of flip-up helmet designs is that they tend to be more aerodynamic than full-face ones, which can benefit riders who want to reduce wind resistance and improve fuel efficiency.
Flip-up helmet designs are also generally lighter than full-face ones, making them more comfortable to wear for extended periods.
On the other hand, flip-up helmet designs have a few potential drawbacks. One concern is that the flip-up mechanism may compromise the helmet’s structural integrity.
In other words, the hinge that allows the chin bar to flip up may create a weak point in the helmet that could compromise its ability to protect the rider in a crash.
Another area for improvement with flip-up helmet designs is that they may be more difficult to use than full-face helmet designs.
For example, getting a secure fit with a flip-up helmet may be more challenging, as the chin bar can interfere with the sealing of the helmet around the neck.
Additionally, flip-up helmet designs may be more prone to leaks or drafts, which can be uncomfortable for the rider in certain weather conditions.
Ultimately, the pros and cons of flip-up helmet designs will depend on the specific design and manufacturer and the rider’s needs and preferences.
Safety Standards for Flip-up Helmets
To be sold to consumers, flip-up helmet designs must adhere to the same safety standards as full-face helmet designs.
Flip-up helmet manufacturers must undergo the same tests to determine their designs’ safety, including impact absorption, penetration resistance, and retention system strength tests.
In addition to these tests, flip-up helmet designs may be subjected to additional testing to ensure that the flip-up mechanism does not compromise the helmet’s structural integrity.
For example, manufacturers may conduct additional impact absorption tests with the chin bar in both the up and down positions to ensure that the helmet provides consistent protection regardless of the position of the chin bar.
Not all flip-up helmet designs are created equal, and the safety ratings of different flip-up helmet models may vary based on the specific design and manufacturer.
Therefore, as with any helmet style, it’s important to research and chooses a flip-up helmet design that meets at least the minimum safety standards set by the DOT or another recognized organization.
This will ensure that you are getting a helmet that has been tested and proven to provide a certain level of protection in the event of a crash or collision.
Real-World Testing of Flip-Up Helmets
A few different sources of real-world testing data can help us assess the safety of flip-up helmet designs.
One such source is crash test data, which can be used to determine how well a helmet design performs in simulated crash scenarios.
While crash test data is not necessarily indicative of how a helmet will perform in a real-world crash, it can provide valuable insights into the protective capabilities of a helmet design.
Another source of real-world testing data is rider feedback. For example, many riders who have worn flip-up helmet designs have shared their experiences with these helmet styles, including their thoughts on their comfort, fit, and overall performance in various riding conditions.
While rider feedback is subjective and may vary from person to person, it can be useful information for riders considering purchasing a flip-up helmet.
Overall, the real-world testing data on flip-up helmet safety is limited, and there needs to be a clear consensus on whether these helmet styles are as safe as full-face helmet designs.
However, it’s worth noting that flip-up helmet designs have been on the market for many years, and countless riders have worn these helmet styles and experienced no issues with their safety.
As with any helmet style, it’s important to research and chooses a flip-up helmet design that meets at least the minimum safety standards set by the DOT or another recognized organization.
This will ensure that you are getting a helmet that has been tested and proven to provide a certain level of protection in the event of a crash or collision.
Additionally, be sure to read reviews and try on different helmet styles to find the one that is most comfortable and fits you best.
Can You Ride with a Flip-Up Helmet Open?
Riding with a flip-up helmet open is generally not recommended, as doing so can significantly reduce the protective capabilities of the helmet.
In addition, when the chin bar of a flip-up helmet is open, it exposes the rider’s face and neck to potential impacts and other hazards, which can significantly increase the risk of injury in the event of a crash or collision.
Riding with a flip-up helmet open may also be uncomfortable for the rider, as it can allow wind, rain, and other elements to enter the helmet and potentially cause distractions or discomfort.
If you need to communicate with others or take a drink while riding, it is generally better to stop and take off your helmet completely rather than try to ride with the chin bar open.
This will allow you to fully remove the helmet and expose your face and neck to the elements, rather than trying to do so while riding at high speeds.
In short, it is generally not recommended to ride with a flip-up helmet open, as doing so can significantly reduce the protective capabilities of the helmet and may be uncomfortable for the rider.
Instead, it is generally better to stop and take off the helmet completely if you need to communicate with others or take a break.
In conclusion
Whether flip-up helmet designs are as safe as full-face helmet designs is not straightforward, and there needs to be a clear consensus on the answer.
While flip-up helmet designs offer a level of versatility and convenience that can be appealing to some riders, there are also potential drawbacks to these helmet styles, such as the potential for compromised structural integrity and difficulty in achieving a secure fit.
However, it’s worth noting that flip-up helmet designs must meet the same safety standards as full-face helmet designs to be sold to consumers.
Some real-world testing data is available to help us assess the safety of these helmet styles. While this data is limited, and the results may vary depending on the specific design and manufacturer, flip-up helmet designs can provide a certain level of protection during a crash or collision.
Ultimately, choosing a flip-up or full-face helmet will depend on the individual rider’s needs and preferences.
It’s important to research, read reviews, and try different helmet styles to find the most comfortable one that fits you best.
Whether you choose a flip-up helmet or a full-face helmet, the most important thing is to wear a helmet that meets at least the minimum safety standards set by the DOT or another recognized organization and to wear it every time you ride.
If your looking for a flip-up helmet then read our list of the best flip up helmets on the market today.
Still not sure about a flip-up helmet? Read our article titled: Is a Flip-Up Motorcycle Helmet Dangerous?